Krishna Deo, S/O Late Baldeo Prasad Gupta, R/O K 44 / 19, Naik Bazar, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221001; Mobile Number 9450541438, email ID kdeo.vns @gmail.com
Customer / Complainant
Versus
1. M/S Epson India Private Limited, Corporate Office, 12th Floor, The Millenia, tower A, No 1. Murphy Road, Ulsoor, Bangalore – 560008
2. Epson (India) p ltd, M 12- M16A, Mezzinine Floor, 89, Hemkunt Chambers, Nehru Place, New Delhi, 110019
3. Mr Murthy, Sr Manager, Customer Service, Epson India Private Limited, Corporate Office, 12th Floor, The Millenia, tower A, No 1. Murphy Road, Ulsoor, Bangalore – 560008
6. Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
7. Priyanshu Jaiswal, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, eluk11@epsonindia.in,
8. Priya Jaiswal, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010.
9. Mr Digvijai Singh, propriter, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010.
10. Mr Devendra Singh, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
11. Mr Sunil Dubey, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
12. Mr Ravi Kumar, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
13. Mr Sandeep Pandey, Area Incharge, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010.
14. Mr Vinod Kumar, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
Opposite parties / Respondents
You opposite parties are hereby being informed as under:
1) That the applicant / complainant is a senior citizen and a consumer of “Printing Services” of Epson L380 color printer bearing serial number X2Q5246838 purchased for his personal use from the authorized dealers of M/S Epson India P Limited, opposite party number 1. The service of which was agreed to be given by the opposite parties 1 to 14 above at the service point being complainant’s residence House No - K 44 / 19, Naik Bazar, Varanasi, 221001, with condition that the consumer is able to use these printing services through the said point of installation of the aforesaid printer by the service provider and connected with consumer’s computer set working in order free from all kinds of set and hardware and software faults / defects.
2) That the aforesaid Epson printer model L380 bearing Serial number X2Q5246838 was purchased by the consumer / complainant from the authorized dealers of you opposite party 1 above being M/S Paytm through National Computech (57159), Bangalore, Karnataka, Pin code 560002 against cash payment of Rs 11,987/- vide cash memo number 29A0005715903186 dated 16.10.2017, vide Shipment number 2948763184, Order number 3980163275, month and year of Import Aug 2017 along with onsite warranty for replacement / repairing against manufacturing defect, defective parts thereat along-with printer hardware and software failure for a period of one year or up-to 30,000 prints at the cost of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above.
(Photocopy of documents Sale invoice already sent by email)
3) That you opposite parties number 1 and 2 above (being the principal service provider) M/S Epson India P Ltd (abbreviated Epson and also referred hereunder as Epson company) at Bangalore and New Delhi, you opposite party number 3 above being the Senior Manager customer services at Epson India P Ltd at Corporate Center Bangalore, you opposite parties number 4 being a DGM of Epson India P Ltd at Regional Controlling office, New Delhi; you opposite party number 5 above being Area Manager U.P. division of the Epson company, agreed to provide onsite printing services and warranty services against the aforesaid printer to the complainant vide Consumer / Customer No IN7004582980 through you opposite parties number 6 to 14 above. You opposite parties number 6 to 14 above being authorized service center, service coordinator, service engineers, owner and authorities of Epson authorized service center in Varanasi and in the capacity of for rendering proper services to the consumer on behalf of you opposite party number 1 above also agreed for rendering of services through Consumer / Customer No IN7004582980.
4) That you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above agreed to provide under warranty after sale services bought by the complainant under the terms and conditions of contract of services as mentioned above in para 1 to 3 of this letter.
Accordingly you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above were legally bound and directly and obliquely responsible to to fulfill customer support and to provide uninterrupted trouble-free printing services with the aforesaid printing machine (Epson L380 printer) sold to the consumer at specified printing speed and trouble free while printing documents and photographs with four color inks in color and in black without producing any fake or unnatural linings, dots or unnatural colors at the point of service i.e. at the residence of the complainant specified in Para 1 above.
(Photocopy of documents Warranty already sent by email)
Photocopy of documents for Consumer number already sent by email)
5) That the aforesaid Epson printer purchased by the consumer failed in working properly on 14.11.2017 spoiling about 249 number of pages used by the consumer in printing of documents through aforesaid printer. The printer produced unnatural and fake lining with dots while printing any document or photos in color in standard quality mode of the aforesaid printer.
The consumer also contacted opposite parties on their mobile numbers to resolve the complaint lodged but all in vain. There had been a deliberate service deficiency on the part of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above and unfair trade practice was applied by you opposite parties to lapse consumers warranty for the aforesaid product in a fraudulent way.
(Call log and complaint numbers
recorded here in para number 8 below)
6) That the defect and deficiency in service given by you opposite parties was of continuing nature which originated and repeated very frequently, more or less daily and remained continuous for number of days since 14.11.2017 up till the last day of lodging this complaint i.e. on dt 10.01.2018 and onwards.
That the complaints against the service deficiency of “printing failure and generating unnatural / fake lining” in standard and high quality modes of the aforesaid printer (being non-repairable manufacturing defect) were not resolved by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above, causing termination of contracted and agreed printing services to the consumer at the point of service.
7) That written and oral complaints were lodged by the consumer, with you opposite parties number 1 to 9 above, through customer care number 18004250011 and email ID on dt 14.11.2017 against the aforesaid non working printer and non-repairable manufacturing defect of the aforesaid printer as under:
A. The aforesaid printer produced unnatural and fake linings and dots while printing any document in standard quality mode of the aforesaid printer within the warranty period,
B. Black and cyan color missing with color shift in printing with standard quality mode of the aforesaid printer working with high configuration computer connectivity with all sorts of software hardware and monitor calibration set free from any malfunction.
C. There was a printer failure and same was not working properly.
D. the complaint of fake lining generation during printing any document being of recurring nature continued and spoiled media and papers up till printing 249 number of pages up-till dt 14.11.2017.
8) That the complaints being unattended and unresolved by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above, within stipulated time limit of 3 days, further complaints were again lodged by the consumer through complaint ID issued by customer care call logs and by emails, the summary of which is given as under:
Date Complaint number Complaint against the aforesaid printer
14.11.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
19.11.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
20.11.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
20.11.2017 4138397 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
23-Nov-17 INC1004152793 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
28.11.2017 4171219 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
29.11.2017 4175245 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
29.11.2017 INC1004176201 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
01.12.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
17.12.2017 by email Prints fake Linings and dots.True Blackand cyan missing with color shift,
faded and fake colors, Complaints remain unresolved,
Copy of printed documents attached (5);
Printer failed in printing true colors of color test document in standard quality mode of the printer.
Original document image in MS office and printed by Epson L380 annexed
17.12.2017 4241714 complaints as above, unattended by service centre
18.12.2017 “INC1004241921” complaint unattended by service Centre and closed with fake report by
Epson Service Center coordinator under directives by Epson Area
Manager Mr Maruti Misra.
21.12.2017 onsite warranty denied by service engineer Mr Sunil Pandey.
22.12.2017 “IN7004582980” Complaint Unattended and unresolved.
24.12.2017 printer lying dead and not working properly, complaint lodged through
email remained unattended, repairing and onsite warranty denied by
Epson Area Manager on mobile.
25.12.2017 Repairing of the defective printer denied by the Epson Area Manager,
No reply to complaint lodged through email
26.12.2017 4267996 Complaint lodged for printer failure.
26,12.2017 “INC1004263779”. Complaint lodged against printer failure
27.12.2017 INW5003308708 Complaint lodged against printer failure
27.12.2017 4275880 Complaint lodged against printer failure
30.12.2017 4289716 Complaint lodged against printer failure,
30.12.2017 INC1004275880 Complaint lodged against printer failure,
03.01.2016 4303580 Complaint lodged against printer failure,
9) That since 14 Nov 2017 up till 03 January 2018 approximately more than 23 call logs were made by the consumer through complaint id issued by Epson Customer Care as recoded in Para number 7 of this letter and written complaints were also made through email with more than 40 reminders.
Consequently. requests / complaints were lodged by the consumer under warranty claim to rectify / remove the faults arising with the non-working printer and requests were made to replace the defective material with a properly working component or printer through Epson company customer care number 18004250011 and through email Ids and mobile numbers of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above.
Wherein you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above willfully terminated customer complaints making manipulated and misleading remarks in Epson company record at your end which was always other than that reported by the customer. Direct refusal to onsite repairing or replacement of defective product sold to the consumer was persistently made by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above under warranty period. The customer was served with a misleading Record issued by you opposite party number 4 above by email on dt 28.12.2017 with false, fabricated and concocted charges willfully levied upon the consumer.
10) That the photocopy of documentary evidences in support of complaints and reminders lodged by the consumer with you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above were sent through email ID. Complaints were also lodged with mobile number of you opposite parties number 3, 4, 5 above along-with you opposite parties 6, 7, 8 , 10 above though SMS on dt 19 Dec 2017 and onwards.
(SMS sent on dt 19.12.2017 already sent by email)
(SMS sent on dt 28.12.2017 already sent by email)
(SMS sent on dt 01.01.2018 already sent by email )
(SMS sent on dt 02.01.2018 already sent by email)
12) That the visiting Epson engineers, you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above, were all the times given access to all facilities including the aforesaid defective printer with original Epson supplied ink, access to wifi, access to engineers personal mobile and laptop connectivity with defective printer, sitting arrangement, power supply, good quality of media, access to computer connectivity with all sorts of software and hardware calibration set free from any malfunction.
Contrary to which the attending service engineers you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above never attended any complaint with a calibrated laptop or mobile device set free from any malfunction to connect the aforesaid printer for checking of the defects while attending to consumer complaints.
13) That except on dated 16.11.2017 on dt 20.11.2017, on dt 21.12.2017 and on 26.12.2017 the complaints made by the complainant were never attended by any Epson technician / Service engineer or by any Epson authority, while the aforesaid printer failed and was not in working order either during or after Epson service engineer’s visit.
Wherein, the remarks recorded by you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above over Customer Service Reports for Epson Printer L380; Serial Number: X2Q5246838 confirming the non manufacturing defect of the aforesaid printer is detailed as under:
Customer Service Report details for Epson Printer L380; Serial Number:
Customer Detail: Krishna Deo, K 44/ 19 Naik Bazar, Varanasi. Mob 9450541438
Date of visit Service Report Sheet Serial No /
RMA slip no Visiting engineer’s name Defect and Fault reported by service engineer on Epson Customer Service Report / RMA slip Consumer’s written complaint on Epson Customer Service Report / RMA slip
16.11.2017 RMA slip No: INW5003215105
Customer Service Report No …Nil, dt 16.11.2017
annexed as B 1 Mr Devendra Singh,
OP No 10 Service type:
Repair and service Consumer’s Remarks:
Printer not working properly in standard quality mode.
Reported problem–
Printing problem
Color missing
Observed problem-
Printing problem
Color missing Customer’s Feedback:
Document with JPEG file is printed with fake linings & fake colors.
Action taken – Service & maintenance Head cleaning done , report generated , page count and line count not recorded in service report.
Rectification Details:
printer printing properly
20.11.2017 Customer Service Report No …Nil dt 20.11.2017
annexed as B 1 Mr Vinod Kumar,
OP No 14 Reported Problem-
Customer not satisfied with printer working Consumer’s own Remarks-
Color variation in printing unresolved.
Observed Problem-
column left blank by service engineer Customer’s Feedback:
Printer Head defective, produces false colors
Action taken-
column left blank Customer’s complaint:
Head cleaning done, report generated and line count not recorded in service report by service engineer.
Rectification Details:
Customer not satisfied with printer working
Paper count :
619
01.12.2017 RMA slip number
INW5003247309
annexed as B 1
Mr Ravi Kumar Gupta,
OPNo 12
And
Sandeep Pandey
OP No 13 Service type:
Repair and service Consumer’s own Remarks-
Printer gives color shift for black and lining with dots appear frequently.
Reported Problem-
Not recorded
Observed Problem-
Not recorded
Action taken- marked:
No Problem Found Customer’s Feedback and complaint:
Head cleaning done, ink consumed, report generated and line count not recorded in service report.
Customer Service Report not issued by service engineer.
Onsite machine report as “Printer Information Check” was also generated by Mr Sandeep Pandey in back date from his Laptop i.e. 01.12.2017 but he refused to sign RMA / Epson customer service report.
Remarks:
Check it No problem found, ink empty, Printer is working fine
Paper count : 684
21.12.2017 Customer Service Report No …Nil dt 21.12.2017
annexed as B 1 Mr Devendra Singh
OP No 10
and
Mr Sunil Dubey,
OP No 10 & 11 Reported Problem-
Color missing Consumer’s own Remarks-
Customer’s complaint on reverse of Customer Service Report.
Other problem:
Printer Nozzle missing
Observed Problem-
Color missing Customer’s Feedback:
Cash back was opted for after an offer by service engineer Sunil Dubey who confirmed the printer to be a wrong product purchased in writing and the fault of printer to be of recurring nature.
मैं अपने प्रिंटर L380 S No S2Q5246338 की मरम्मत नहीं कराना चाहता, मरम्मत के बाद भी Head cleaning वगैरह से शिकायत निराकरण का आश्वासन न होने से मैं इस प्रिंटर को वापस करके इसके कीमत की वापसी चाहता हूँ इस प्रिंटर से exact color नहीं मिलता है और lining बन रहा है
Action taken-
Service and Maintainance
Rectification Details:
Customer has purchased wrong product
Customer not repair printer
Nozzle print: marked as printed Customer’s complaint:
Head cleaning done, ink consumed, report generated on page count 1102 signed by Sunil Dubey and line count not recorded in service report.
Paper count and Line count:
unrecorded
Other Remarks: Nozzle failure
26.12.2017 RMA slip number INW5003300806
annexed as B 1 Sandeep Pandey
and
Mr Vinod Kumar
OP No 13 & 14 Service type:
Repair and service Customer’s complaint on Customer Service Report:
Repairing denied by Epson service engineers on 26.12.2017. Complaint remains unresolved.
Reported Problem-
unrecorded
Observed Problem-
unrecorded
Action taken-
Unrecorded, left unmarked Service engineers acted unlawfully within customer’s premises and infringed privacy.
Rectification Details:
unrecorded Customer’s complaint:
Head cleaning done, ink consumed, report generated on page count 1102 not recorded in service report
Remarks:
प्रिंटर में इंक नहीं है इसलिए रिपेयर नहीं हो सकता Service engineers refused to issue Customer Service Report. Made photographs turning the printer ink tank vertically up.
14) Wherein, the unresolved and unattended complaints were written off by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above from back of the customer and without customer’s knowledge with a malafide intension to lapse the warranty period for the aforesaid Epson printer.
You opposite parties made pre-planned force closure of complaints and changed the nature of complaint lodged by the consumer willfully manipulated with fake, contradictory, concocted remarks through SMS and email reply as under:
Consumer’s complaint lodged with documentary evidences emailed with opposite parties. Concocted and fabricated Remarks conveyed to consumer.
Complaint dt 14,11.2017 to 20.11.2017
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode “printer is working fine”,
Prints fake Linings and dots .True Black and cyan colr missing with color shift in standad quality mode of the aforesaid printer, customer need to photo printer, as a actual display photo print same to same want by print photo,
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode,
Prints fake Linings and dots .True Black and cyan colr missing with color shift in standad quality mode of the aforesaid printer, “Call logged on 20.11.2017 against the complaint ID INC1004138397 reporting back the same issue of color mismatch compared to system monitor, printer was working fine and no issues found.
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode,
“The issue reported was the same hence explained customer”
if you are looking for better color reproduction from the printer , you have to go for six color printer,.
Complaint dt 19,11.2017
Printer Head failure / Printer Nozzle missing reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 on Epson Customer Service report by Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh
Complaint dt 22.11.2017
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode,
Prints fake Linings and dots .True Black and cyan color missing with color shift in standad quality mode of the aforesaid printer, “This time you are reported the different problem “Lining Issue” 22.12.2017
“Again the same points if you are interested to repair the same printer we will send the engineer once again
Printer Head failure / Printer Nozzle missing was reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 which was confirmed by Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh. One more things the media you are using is not a good quality of media …
Complaint dt 29.11.2017
Wherein call log against complaint ID INC1004176201 dt 29.11.2017 was closed with manipulated and concocted record as attended.
complaint unattended by service Centre and closed with fake report “Since you were out of station, call was rejected and requested to relog once you are in town.” Complaint lodged against printer failure “Pls refer my attached mail and confirm If you want to repair the same printer.
Already you are rejected to repair the same printer ….one more things our engineer is not consumed any ink because hardly we are attended your calls 2 times only.
Complaint lodged against printer failure still I am waiting your confirmation that you want to repair or Not
Complaint dt 21.12.2017
Printer Head failure / Printer Nozzle missing was reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 which was confirmed by Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh
The Epson Service Engineer Mr Sunil Dubey accompanying with Mr Devendar Singh attending the aforesaid complaint offered the customer to take back a refund for the defective printer stating that the problem lies due to non repairable manufacturing defect and of recurring nature, “You had logged the call but not allowed and supported engineer to check the printer, you had removed all ink from the printer and not allowed to check for any trouble other than color mismatch which you repeatedly reporting.
But understand that you were demanding the replacement of the same issue of color mismatch but replacement will not meet your expectation which is beyond the specification of the printer.”
“False claim, Service Center never denied onsite support. FYI call was attended by our engineer Mr Devendar Singh on 21.12.2017.”
Complaint dt 26.12.2017
Service engineers denied to onsite warranty at the cost of you opposite party number 1.
Service engineers opposite parties number 13 and 14 above infringed the privacy of the consumer and acted fraudulently against the interest of the consumer. When our engineer was tried to take the Photograph you also denied the same and stopped to take the photograph …you are also not signing on call report also ….
Today Engineer visited at Customer side found CIS Tank is empty, and Customer is not ready to provide INK for repairing purpose.
(Concocted service remarks already objected by email)
15) That a Nozzle failure was already notified by Epson service engineers you opposite party number 10 above on dt 21.12.2017. The aforesaid Epson printer model L380, Serial number X2Q5246838 was handed over to you opposite parties number 10 and 11above for repairing on dt 21.12.2017 and on dt 26.12.2017.
And it was the absolute responsibility of Epson Service Center you opposite parties number 6 to 9 along-with you opposite parties number 10 and 14 to carry and bring with them sufficient quantity of Epson original ink, good quality media and other necessary Epson components required at the point of onsite warranty for wastage, testing and replacement during repairing of aforesaid Epson printer within warranty period. Moreover it was also the absolute responsibility of you opposite parties number 6 to 14 to conform free supply all requisite basic requirements and components to the consumer during onsite warranty for repairing from the Epson authorities you opposite parties number 1 to 5.
16) That the printer Head failure / printer Nozzle missing was reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 which was confirmed by (Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh) you opposite party number 10 above on Customer Service Report issued on dt 21.12.2017.
Print Nozzle check pattern report was taken out from the aforesaid printer at page number 1102 by you opposite parties number 10 above and also signed by you opposite party on dt 21.12.2017 but onsite repairing was denied and a cash refund was offered by you opposite parties number 11 who accompanied with Service Engineer Mr Devendar Singh you opposite parties number 10 above.
You opposite party number 11 above (being Epson Service Engineer Mr Sunil Dubey) did not suggest onsite repairing and asked the complainant to opt for a cash refund which was a fraudulent attempt on his part to escape from the complaint against deficiency in services. The customer was also misguided by you opposite parties number 11 to sign a request for that on Customer Service Report dt 21.12.2017.
Print time with the aforesaid printer being 5 minutes 25 seconds in High quality mode for glossy paper A4 size, which was much higher than company specification for L380 printer model.
Ink was consumed in printer maintenance / head cleaning by visiting Epson service engineers and printer flaws and failure to print accurately with true colors could not be rectified during repairing and head cleaning by Epson Service engineers.
You opposite party number 11 above carried the Epson CD owned by the consumer and did not return customer’s Epson printer software CD back to the consumer on date of his visit i.e. 21.12.2017. He even never received customer’s mobile calls.
Complaint caused due to a non-repairable manufacturing defect and being of a recurring nature could not be resolved in repairing and printer head cleaning by the attending Epson service engineers. A fraudulent denial to replace the aforesaid defective product was made by you opposite party number 10 above.
That you opposite parties number 5 and 7 above accepted through email message for having attended consumer complaints through service engineers only for two times out of 23 call logs onwards 14.11.2017 uptill 03.01.2018.
Consequently, written complaint was lodged through email with Epson Area Manager, Mr Maruti Misra, you opposite party umber 5 above, whereas the customer objected to all misleading and wrong remarks willfully created by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above.
Wherein all call logs recorded in para 4 above were fraudulently reported by you opposite parties number 1 to 13 above as attended with fake, concocted, willfully created and manipulated reports raised against complaints lodged by the customer and a force closure of complaints was made.
Service and repairing report for the aforesaid Epson printer was not updated on Epson Web page.
Customer’s complaints against printer head failure and nozzle missing causing printing of unnatural and fake lining in standard mode along with printer failure to print black and cyan color were fraudulently changed into the record of Epson company by you opposite parties 1 to 14 above, the copy of which emailed by the company DGM Epson India P Ltd New Delhi on 28.12.2017.
17) That you opposite party number 5 above being responsible to fulfill customer support onsite always ill-treated the consumer through concocted email messages, misleading conversation on mobile, by criminal offences of infringing consumer’s privacy within consumer’s premises and private room by making video and voice recording done through you opposite party number 13 and 14 above without knowledge of the consumer. The privacy of third party not related with the matter was deliberately infringed under instigation from you opposite party number 5 above on mobile conversation with his service engineer. Repairing of Epson printer was denied in a pre -planned and illegal manner by the authorities of Epson Company.
You opposite party number 5 above flatly denied to depute any service engineer for onsite repairing of the aforesaid defective product and always remained negligent in performing customer services. You opposite party not only refused to intimate Epson Lucknow Area Office address but also misbehaved with the customer in an abusive manner on 26.12.2017.
The act of deputing service engineers with pre thought malafide intention to willfully make photographs and video recording through you opposite parties number 12 and 13 above, on dt 26.12.2017 clearly shows a pre thought planning for not getting the printer repaired and to safeguard you opposite party number 5 above from customer’s complaint against entire ink consumption by visiting service engineers during multiple Head cleaning on previous dates of complaint and to put the customer to monetary losses.
(email message dt 26.12.2017sent by you opposite party
number 5 above already sent by email)
18) That printer Head cleaning and repairing was done with ink consumption from the aforesaid printer ink tank during repairing and multiple head cleaning by you opposite parties number 13 and 14 above on dt 26.12.2017, but the aforesaid printer failed to properly print document with jpeg files in standard quality mode and continued producing fake linings with fake color.
Wherein Head cleaning report was also generated by you opposite parties but you opposite parties refused to repair the defective printer onsite leaving the complaint unresolved irrespective of the fact that the aforesaid printer contained original ink supplied by Epson company after multiple head cleaning by the you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above.
You opposite parties number 13 and 14 above Mr Sandeep Pandey and Vinod Kumar being the Service engineers, acted unlawfully on dt 26.12.2017 as a visiting engineer in privacy area of the consumer not being publically visible. You opposite parties acted illegally with a pre thought motive to deny repairing under warranty, misbehaved with the consumer, infringed the privacy of customer’s family members being third party under instigation and mobile conversation with you opposite party number 5 above on dt 26.12.2017.
Further you opposite party number 13 and 14 above illegally made a video and fabricated voice record after provoking the victim without his knowledge and consent which they should not have done as service engineers, and the second, that you opposite parties attempted to record video of victims family members and belongings inside private room within premises of the customer for which they were not a party, performed a criminal offence latter published that information in public through emails with a motive to causing annoyance / inconvenience, to deceive and to mislead the addressee and recipient.
Head cleaning and repairing was done with ink consumption and report was generated by you opposite party number 13 above. When asked by the customer to record all requisite columns of Epson Service Report as Reported problem, Observed problem and Rectification details you opposite parties willfully left the same blank to deceive the consumer. You opposite parties even did not ssue Epson Customer Service Report to the consumer. It implies a well thought and preplanned intention on the part of the Epson Service Center Engineers you opposite parties number 12 and 13 above under instigation from Epson authorities you opposite parties number 3 to 5 above to commit a crime for not attending to repairing of the printer, which is clear from the message emailed to the consumer by Epson Area Manager Mr Maruti Misra you opposite party number 5.
Service Report Columns as Reported problem, Observed problem and Rectification details willfully were left blank by you opposite parties to illegally make consumer’s warranty claim null and voide, in spite of Head cleaning and repairing being done with ink consumption from the aforesaid defective Epson printer and Head Cleaning report generated by you opposite party number 10 above.
Since the aforesaid printer failed to print document with jpeg files properly in standard quality mode and continued producing unnatural and fake linings with fake color, the consumer recorded his remarks against unresolved complaint on back of the Epson Customer Service Report RMA number INW5003215105 issued by the service engineer.
(Customer Service Report RMA number INW5003215105
already sent by email)
19) That the willful refusal to repair the defective printer by by you opposite parties 1 to 14 above on dated 21.12.2017 and on dated 26.12.2017 is considered as unfair trade practices and an illegal act for making null and void customer’s warranty claim for replacement of defective Epson printer for which the customer was legally entitled for.
The customer informed of the aforesaid printer to contain original Epson ink supplied by you opposite party number 1 above and also asked you opposite parties number 1 to 14 on dt 29.12.2017 to supply ink and submit the bill after repairing and also requested to you opposite party number 4 above through email, which you opposite parties number 1 to 14 have unlawfully denied on grounds that original ink was not available with you opposite parties number 6 to 13 above.
You opposite parties number 1 to 14 above even failed to inform the customer as to what quantity of printer ink was needed by you opposite parties number 6 to 14 each time they attend customer's complaint and how much quantity of ink was to be consumed to avoid repairing / replacement of the aforesaid defective and not working Epson printer.
20) That repair and complaint status for the aforesaid Epson printer illegally remained unavailable against each and every complaint number at Epson web page https://customer.epson.co.in/customer/repair.do#/IN and complaint status was never displayed on site by you opposite parties nuber 1 to 14 above.
Moreover the attending Epson Service engineers never issued the consumer any Epson Service Report / Job Card with printed serial number.
21) That after sale service warranty was all the times denied by you opposite parties against the agreed terms and conditions of onsite repairing or replacement of defective material / product with service ink and further illegally demanding to supply the consumer with unlimited amount of extra bottles of ink other than that contained in aforesaid printer ink tank. Services bought from the opposite parties remained terminated even due to refusal to supply original Epson ink by you opposite party number 1 to 14 above against valid cash memo.
You opposite parties number 1 to 14 never informed the customer nor replied when asked through email message as to the quantity of ink was required and the shop selling Epson ink. You opposite parties even failed to inform the customer as to what sort of repairing was to be done with aforesaid printer and attempted to escape from all complaint call logs made by the consumer.
Whereas, the consumer also visited you opposite party number 6 above with the aforesaid defective and non-working Epson printer and requested to deposit the same with you opposite parties number 6 to 9 above, but you opposite parties refused to do so.
22) That there had been a deficiency in services on the part of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above. You opposite party number 4 above created a willful illegal force closure of all unattended and unresolved complaints with concocted, manipulated, misleading and fake remarks in Epson company records at your end, copy of which was sent by to the consumer by you opposite party number 4 above by email dt 28.12.2017 denying onsite warranty for replacement of the defective product.
(Refer to concocted service remarks dt 28.12.2017 already sent by email)
23) Wherein onsite repairing being willfully denied by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above, a warranty claim for replacement of the defective product was made by the customer through written letter dt 19.12.2017 sent by India Post on dt 21.12.2017 and a request was made to consider the same within 15 days of the date of this letter i.e. on or before 04 Jan 2018 with you opposite parties number 1 and 6 above, but all in vain.
(Mailing proof, Postal receipt dt 21.12.2017 already sent by email)
24) That you opposite parties 1 to 14 above failed to provide uninterrupted / deficiency-less services to the consumer / complainant. Deficiency in services of continuing nature persisted with aforesaid Epson printer as frequent production of unnatural and fake lines in printing through the aforesaid Epson printing machine and of access to machine failure continued since 14.11.2012 up till dt 03.01.2018.
25) That you opposite parties being involved in practice of "planned obsolescence" - creating and selling products pre-designed for failure at some point and to lapse warranty period so that consumers be enticed to replace the product within warranty period and without any extension of warranty period.
And by using this techniques for placing a product on the market pre-designed for failure deliberately aimed to reduce Inkjet printers lifetime in order to increase the replacement rate, you opposite parties are responsible for the same. You opposite parties are involved in selling ink jet printers with pre-designed Head and Nozzles which fails and blocks prematurely even when "substantial ink" remains in the printer tank. You opposite parties by being involved into the breach of contract with its customer who is entitled to use all the ink in the ink tank trouble free. The aforesaid Epson Inkjet printer sold to the consumer is an evidence to that and the consumer is a victim of that.
26) That you opposite parties were all the time negligent after receiving repeated and continued complaints and reminders in making good on-site under warranty claim made by the customer against the recurring and non-repairable manufacturing defect of the aforesaid defective and non-working Epson printer and even thereafter whenever the complainant visited you opposite parties 6 to 9 personally for removal and resolution of complaints against deficiency in service and service failure.
27) That you opposite parties number 1 to 14 deliberately recorded (1) Print lead / Lamp warranty end date (2) Spare part warranty end date and (3) Labor warranty end date to be 27/09/2018 instead of 23.10.2017 based on the date of online delivery to the consumer on dt 24.10.2017.
You opposite parties have willfully terminated the contracted service since 14.11.2018 up till the printer remains dead and warranty made null and void defrauding the consumer.
28) That there had been a deficiency in services from the side of you opposite parties’ number 1 to14 above. Consequently final complaint was lodged by the complainant on dt 03.01.2017 through customer care number against printer failure, service failure, writing off all previous complaints with concocted and fabricated remarks, deficient services, fraudulent acts and unfair trade practices on the part of the service provider respondent / you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above being directly and vicariously liable.
29) That the customer / complainant also requested you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above vide letter dt 19.12.2017 to do the needful to replace the above mentioned defective Epson L380 printer under warranty claim by another working Epson Printer in any brand with equivalent price and value on or before 04.01.2018 and to extend the warranty of the aforesaid Epson printer for a period the complaint remained unattended and unresolved, but all in vain. Onsite repairing of the aforesaid printer has been flatly and directly denied by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above by applying unfair trade practices for which you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above may be held liable into the court of justice.
30) That the complainant is a consumer of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above through Consumer / Customer No IN7004582980, under Section 2 (d) of Consumer Protection Act 1986 and there is a deficiency of service on the part of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above as stated in para number 5 to para number 29 of this letter.
You opposite parties number 1 to 14 above have willfully attempted to lapse the warranty for the aforesaid defective printer since 14.11.2017, caused the customer with a great monetary loss of Rupees 11,987/- being the price of the aforesaid printer paid, a sum of Rupees 5,000/ as typing and communication charges paid, loss through paper and media damages Rs 1000/-,, loss through ink wastage Rs 1056/-, loss through postal communication and internet charges Rs 2000/-, a sum of Rs 200,000/ being the amount of loss goddwill, and a sum of Rs 10,00,000/- through mental tension and agony total amount being Rs 12,21,043/- (Rs twelve lac twenty one thousand forty three only) along with other losses to be accessed by the legal advisor which you please are requested to pay to the consumer / complainant / undersigned within 3 days of the date of this letter i.e, on or before 14.01.2018 failing which the consumer shall be bound to refer the matter to his legal advisors for further legal action and compensation of all losses and damages caused by you parties into the matter on risk and responsibility of you opposite parties.
Krishna Deo,
Krishna Deo, S/O Late Baldeo Prasad Gupta, R/O K 44 / 19, Naik Bazar, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221001; Mobile Number 9450541438, email ID kdeo.vns @gmail.com
Customer / Complainant
Versus
1. M/S Epson India Private Limited, Corporate Office, 12th Floor, The Millenia, tower A, No 1. Murphy Road, Ulsoor, Bangalore – 560008
2. Epson (India) p ltd, M 12- M16A, Mezzinine Floor, 89, Hemkunt Chambers, Nehru Place, New Delhi, 110019
3. Mr Murthy, Sr Manager, Customer Service, Epson India Private Limited, Corporate Office, 12th Floor, The Millenia, tower A, No 1. Murphy Road, Ulsoor, Bangalore – 560008
4. Mr Vishwanath.S, DGM, Epson India Pvt Ltd. M12-M16A, Mezzanine Floor, No.89, Hemkunt Chambers, Nehru PlaceNew Delhi – 110019, Mob : 9899551300
5. Mr Maruti Misra, Epson Area Manager (U.P.), Epson India Private Limited, Epson Inkjet Printer Division, Forbes Bradma Automation, Lucknow. maruthi@eid.epson.co.in,
6. Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
7. Priyanshu Jaiswal, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, eluk11@epsonindia.in,
8. Priya Jaiswal, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010.
9. Mr Digvijai Singh, propriter, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010.
10. Mr Devendra Singh, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
11. Mr Sunil Dubey, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
12. Mr Ravi Kumar, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
13. Mr Sandeep Pandey, Area Incharge, Epson Authorised Service Centre, Astron Computer Service, 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010.
14. Mr Vinod Kumar, Service Engineer, Epson Authorised Service Center, M/S Astron Computer Services (ELUK11), 19 Gandhi Nagar, Sigra, Varanasi, (U.P.) 221010, Customer Care Toll Free number 18004250011
Opposite parties / Respondents
You opposite parties are hereby being informed as under:
1) That the applicant / complainant is a senior citizen and a consumer of “Printing Services” of Epson L380 color printer bearing serial number X2Q5246838 purchased for his personal use from the authorized dealers of M/S Epson India P Limited, opposite party number 1. The service of which was agreed to be given by the opposite parties 1 to 14 above at the service point being complainant’s residence House No - K 44 / 19, Naik Bazar, Varanasi, 221001, with condition that the consumer is able to use these printing services through the said point of installation of the aforesaid printer by the service provider and connected with consumer’s computer set working in order free from all kinds of set and hardware and software faults / defects.
2) That the aforesaid Epson printer model L380 bearing Serial number X2Q5246838 was purchased by the consumer / complainant from the authorized dealers of you opposite party 1 above being M/S Paytm through National Computech (57159), Bangalore, Karnataka, Pin code 560002 against cash payment of Rs 11,987/- vide cash memo number 29A0005715903186 dated 16.10.2017, vide Shipment number 2948763184, Order number 3980163275, month and year of Import Aug 2017 along with onsite warranty for replacement / repairing against manufacturing defect, defective parts thereat along-with printer hardware and software failure for a period of one year or up-to 30,000 prints at the cost of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above.
(Photocopy of documents Sale invoice already sent by email)
3) That you opposite parties number 1 and 2 above (being the principal service provider) M/S Epson India P Ltd (abbreviated Epson and also referred hereunder as Epson company) at Bangalore and New Delhi, you opposite party number 3 above being the Senior Manager customer services at Epson India P Ltd at Corporate Center Bangalore, you opposite parties number 4 being a DGM of Epson India P Ltd at Regional Controlling office, New Delhi; you opposite party number 5 above being Area Manager U.P. division of the Epson company, agreed to provide onsite printing services and warranty services against the aforesaid printer to the complainant vide Consumer / Customer No IN7004582980 through you opposite parties number 6 to 14 above. You opposite parties number 6 to 14 above being authorized service center, service coordinator, service engineers, owner and authorities of Epson authorized service center in Varanasi and in the capacity of for rendering proper services to the consumer on behalf of you opposite party number 1 above also agreed for rendering of services through Consumer / Customer No IN7004582980.
4) That you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above agreed to provide under warranty after sale services bought by the complainant under the terms and conditions of contract of services as mentioned above in para 1 to 3 of this letter.
Accordingly you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above were legally bound and directly and obliquely responsible to to fulfill customer support and to provide uninterrupted trouble-free printing services with the aforesaid printing machine (Epson L380 printer) sold to the consumer at specified printing speed and trouble free while printing documents and photographs with four color inks in color and in black without producing any fake or unnatural linings, dots or unnatural colors at the point of service i.e. at the residence of the complainant specified in Para 1 above.
(Photocopy of documents Warranty already sent by email)
Photocopy of documents for Consumer number already sent by email)
5) That the aforesaid Epson printer purchased by the consumer failed in working properly on 14.11.2017 spoiling about 249 number of pages used by the consumer in printing of documents through aforesaid printer. The printer produced unnatural and fake lining with dots while printing any document or photos in color in standard quality mode of the aforesaid printer.
The consumer also contacted opposite parties on their mobile numbers to resolve the complaint lodged but all in vain. There had been a deliberate service deficiency on the part of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above and unfair trade practice was applied by you opposite parties to lapse consumers warranty for the aforesaid product in a fraudulent way.
(Call log and complaint numbers
recorded here in para number 8 below)
6) That the defect and deficiency in service given by you opposite parties was of continuing nature which originated and repeated very frequently, more or less daily and remained continuous for number of days since 14.11.2017 up till the last day of lodging this complaint i.e. on dt 10.01.2018 and onwards.
That the complaints against the service deficiency of “printing failure and generating unnatural / fake lining” in standard and high quality modes of the aforesaid printer (being non-repairable manufacturing defect) were not resolved by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above, causing termination of contracted and agreed printing services to the consumer at the point of service.
7) That written and oral complaints were lodged by the consumer, with you opposite parties number 1 to 9 above, through customer care number 18004250011 and email ID on dt 14.11.2017 against the aforesaid non working printer and non-repairable manufacturing defect of the aforesaid printer as under:
A. The aforesaid printer produced unnatural and fake linings and dots while printing any document in standard quality mode of the aforesaid printer within the warranty period,
B. Black and cyan color missing with color shift in printing with standard quality mode of the aforesaid printer working with high configuration computer connectivity with all sorts of software hardware and monitor calibration set free from any malfunction.
C. There was a printer failure and same was not working properly.
D. the complaint of fake lining generation during printing any document being of recurring nature continued and spoiled media and papers up till printing 249 number of pages up-till dt 14.11.2017.
8) That the complaints being unattended and unresolved by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above, within stipulated time limit of 3 days, further complaints were again lodged by the consumer through complaint ID issued by customer care call logs and by emails, the summary of which is given as under:
Date Complaint number Complaint against the aforesaid printer
14.11.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
19.11.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
20.11.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
20.11.2017 4138397 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
23-Nov-17 INC1004152793 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
28.11.2017 4171219 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
29.11.2017 4175245 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
29.11.2017 INC1004176201 Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
01.12.2017 by email Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode
17.12.2017 by email Prints fake Linings and dots.True Blackand cyan missing with color shift,
faded and fake colors, Complaints remain unresolved,
Copy of printed documents attached (5);
Printer failed in printing true colors of color test document in standard quality mode of the printer.
Original document image in MS office and printed by Epson L380 annexed
17.12.2017 4241714 complaints as above, unattended by service centre
18.12.2017 “INC1004241921” complaint unattended by service Centre and closed with fake report by
Epson Service Center coordinator under directives by Epson Area
Manager Mr Maruti Misra.
21.12.2017 onsite warranty denied by service engineer Mr Sunil Pandey.
22.12.2017 “IN7004582980” Complaint Unattended and unresolved.
24.12.2017 printer lying dead and not working properly, complaint lodged through
email remained unattended, repairing and onsite warranty denied by
Epson Area Manager on mobile.
25.12.2017 Repairing of the defective printer denied by the Epson Area Manager,
No reply to complaint lodged through email
26.12.2017 4267996 Complaint lodged for printer failure.
26,12.2017 “INC1004263779”. Complaint lodged against printer failure
27.12.2017 INW5003308708 Complaint lodged against printer failure
27.12.2017 4275880 Complaint lodged against printer failure
30.12.2017 4289716 Complaint lodged against printer failure,
30.12.2017 INC1004275880 Complaint lodged against printer failure,
03.01.2016 4303580 Complaint lodged against printer failure,
9) That since 14 Nov 2017 up till 03 January 2018 approximately more than 23 call logs were made by the consumer through complaint id issued by Epson Customer Care as recoded in Para number 7 of this letter and written complaints were also made through email with more than 40 reminders.
Consequently. requests / complaints were lodged by the consumer under warranty claim to rectify / remove the faults arising with the non-working printer and requests were made to replace the defective material with a properly working component or printer through Epson company customer care number 18004250011 and through email Ids and mobile numbers of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above.
Wherein you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above willfully terminated customer complaints making manipulated and misleading remarks in Epson company record at your end which was always other than that reported by the customer. Direct refusal to onsite repairing or replacement of defective product sold to the consumer was persistently made by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above under warranty period. The customer was served with a misleading Record issued by you opposite party number 4 above by email on dt 28.12.2017 with false, fabricated and concocted charges willfully levied upon the consumer.
10) That the photocopy of documentary evidences in support of complaints and reminders lodged by the consumer with you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above were sent through email ID. Complaints were also lodged with mobile number of you opposite parties number 3, 4, 5 above along-with you opposite parties 6, 7, 8 , 10 above though SMS on dt 19 Dec 2017 and onwards.
(SMS sent on dt 19.12.2017 already sent by email)
(SMS sent on dt 28.12.2017 already sent by email)
(SMS sent on dt 01.01.2018 already sent by email )
(SMS sent on dt 02.01.2018 already sent by email)
11) That complaints and reminders were also sent to opposite parties number 1 to 14 above vide email ID as under:
calllog@epsonindia.in, epsonvaranasi@gmail.com, eluk11@epsonindia.in, registration@epso.in, nolly.d@ein.epson.co.id, epsonvaranasi@gmail.com, eluk11@epsonindia.in, calllog@epsonindia.in, lizza.s@ein.epson.co.id, jeihan.wa@ein.epson.co.id, vishwanath@eid.epson.co.in. ramasundaram@eid.epson.co.in, maruti@eid.epson.co.in, eco@exc.epson.co.jp, supportme@epson.co.uk,toshiyuki.kasai@eid.epson.co.in, toshiyuki.kasai@eid.epson.co.in, mark@dtkme.com, alona@alnasera.com / caysee@alnasera.com, epsonstore@ea.epson.com, Shinozaki.atsushi@exc.epson.co.jp, newsroom@ea.epson.com, latinmanager@ea.epson.com
12) That the visiting Epson engineers, you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above, were all the times given access to all facilities including the aforesaid defective printer with original Epson supplied ink, access to wifi, access to engineers personal mobile and laptop connectivity with defective printer, sitting arrangement, power supply, good quality of media, access to computer connectivity with all sorts of software and hardware calibration set free from any malfunction.
Contrary to which the attending service engineers you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above never attended any complaint with a calibrated laptop or mobile device set free from any malfunction to connect the aforesaid printer for checking of the defects while attending to consumer complaints.
13) That except on dated 16.11.2017 on dt 20.11.2017, on dt 21.12.2017 and on 26.12.2017 the complaints made by the complainant were never attended by any Epson technician / Service engineer or by any Epson authority, while the aforesaid printer failed and was not in working order either during or after Epson service engineer’s visit.
Wherein, the remarks recorded by you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above over Customer Service Reports for Epson Printer L380; Serial Number: X2Q5246838 confirming the non manufacturing defect of the aforesaid printer is detailed as under:
Customer Service Report details for Epson Printer L380; Serial Number:
Customer Detail: Krishna Deo, K 44/ 19 Naik Bazar, Varanasi. Mob 9450541438
Date of visit Service Report Sheet Serial No /
RMA slip no Visiting engineer’s name Defect and Fault reported by service engineer on Epson Customer Service Report / RMA slip Consumer’s written complaint on Epson Customer Service Report / RMA slip
16.11.2017 RMA slip No: INW5003215105
Customer Service Report No …Nil, dt 16.11.2017
annexed as B 1 Mr Devendra Singh,
OP No 10 Service type:
Repair and service Consumer’s Remarks:
Printer not working properly in standard quality mode.
Reported problem–
Printing problem
Color missing
Observed problem-
Printing problem
Color missing Customer’s Feedback:
Document with JPEG file is printed with fake linings & fake colors.
Action taken – Service & maintenance Head cleaning done , report generated , page count and line count not recorded in service report.
Rectification Details:
printer printing properly
20.11.2017 Customer Service Report No …Nil dt 20.11.2017
annexed as B 1 Mr Vinod Kumar,
OP No 14 Reported Problem-
Customer not satisfied with printer working Consumer’s own Remarks-
Color variation in printing unresolved.
Observed Problem-
column left blank by service engineer Customer’s Feedback:
Printer Head defective, produces false colors
Action taken-
column left blank Customer’s complaint:
Head cleaning done, report generated and line count not recorded in service report by service engineer.
Rectification Details:
Customer not satisfied with printer working
Paper count :
619
01.12.2017 RMA slip number
INW5003247309
annexed as B 1
Mr Ravi Kumar Gupta,
OPNo 12
And
Sandeep Pandey
OP No 13 Service type:
Repair and service Consumer’s own Remarks-
Printer gives color shift for black and lining with dots appear frequently.
Reported Problem-
Not recorded
Observed Problem-
Not recorded
Action taken- marked:
No Problem Found Customer’s Feedback and complaint:
Head cleaning done, ink consumed, report generated and line count not recorded in service report.
Customer Service Report not issued by service engineer.
Onsite machine report as “Printer Information Check” was also generated by Mr Sandeep Pandey in back date from his Laptop i.e. 01.12.2017 but he refused to sign RMA / Epson customer service report.
Remarks:
Check it No problem found, ink empty, Printer is working fine
Paper count : 684
21.12.2017 Customer Service Report No …Nil dt 21.12.2017
annexed as B 1 Mr Devendra Singh
OP No 10
and
Mr Sunil Dubey,
OP No 10 & 11 Reported Problem-
Color missing Consumer’s own Remarks-
Customer’s complaint on reverse of Customer Service Report.
Other problem:
Printer Nozzle missing
Observed Problem-
Color missing Customer’s Feedback:
Cash back was opted for after an offer by service engineer Sunil Dubey who confirmed the printer to be a wrong product purchased in writing and the fault of printer to be of recurring nature.
मैं अपने प्रिंटर L380 S No S2Q5246338 की मरम्मत नहीं कराना चाहता, मरम्मत के बाद भी Head cleaning वगैरह से शिकायत निराकरण का आश्वासन न होने से मैं इस प्रिंटर को वापस करके इसके कीमत की वापसी चाहता हूँ इस प्रिंटर से exact color नहीं मिलता है और lining बन रहा है
Action taken-
Service and Maintainance
Rectification Details:
Customer has purchased wrong product
Customer not repair printer
Nozzle print: marked as printed Customer’s complaint:
Head cleaning done, ink consumed, report generated on page count 1102 signed by Sunil Dubey and line count not recorded in service report.
Paper count and Line count:
unrecorded
Other Remarks: Nozzle failure
26.12.2017 RMA slip number INW5003300806
annexed as B 1 Sandeep Pandey
and
Mr Vinod Kumar
OP No 13 & 14 Service type:
Repair and service Customer’s complaint on Customer Service Report:
Repairing denied by Epson service engineers on 26.12.2017. Complaint remains unresolved.
Reported Problem-
unrecorded
Observed Problem-
unrecorded
Action taken-
Unrecorded, left unmarked Service engineers acted unlawfully within customer’s premises and infringed privacy.
Rectification Details:
unrecorded Customer’s complaint:
Head cleaning done, ink consumed, report generated on page count 1102 not recorded in service report
Remarks:
प्रिंटर में इंक नहीं है इसलिए रिपेयर नहीं हो सकता Service engineers refused to issue Customer Service Report. Made photographs turning the printer ink tank vertically up.
14) Wherein, the unresolved and unattended complaints were written off by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above from back of the customer and without customer’s knowledge with a malafide intension to lapse the warranty period for the aforesaid Epson printer.
You opposite parties made pre-planned force closure of complaints and changed the nature of complaint lodged by the consumer willfully manipulated with fake, contradictory, concocted remarks through SMS and email reply as under:
Consumer’s complaint lodged with documentary evidences emailed with opposite parties. Concocted and fabricated Remarks conveyed to consumer.
Complaint dt 14,11.2017 to 20.11.2017
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode “printer is working fine”,
Prints fake Linings and dots .True Black and cyan colr missing with color shift in standad quality mode of the aforesaid printer, customer need to photo printer, as a actual display photo print same to same want by print photo,
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode,
Prints fake Linings and dots .True Black and cyan colr missing with color shift in standad quality mode of the aforesaid printer, “Call logged on 20.11.2017 against the complaint ID INC1004138397 reporting back the same issue of color mismatch compared to system monitor, printer was working fine and no issues found.
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode,
“The issue reported was the same hence explained customer”
if you are looking for better color reproduction from the printer , you have to go for six color printer,.
Complaint dt 19,11.2017
Printer Head failure / Printer Nozzle missing reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 on Epson Customer Service report by Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh
Complaint dt 22.11.2017
Linings and dots, Black missing with color shift in standard quality mode,
Prints fake Linings and dots .True Black and cyan color missing with color shift in standad quality mode of the aforesaid printer, “This time you are reported the different problem “Lining Issue” 22.12.2017
“Again the same points if you are interested to repair the same printer we will send the engineer once again
Printer Head failure / Printer Nozzle missing was reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 which was confirmed by Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh. One more things the media you are using is not a good quality of media …
Complaint dt 29.11.2017
Wherein call log against complaint ID INC1004176201 dt 29.11.2017 was closed with manipulated and concocted record as attended.
complaint unattended by service Centre and closed with fake report “Since you were out of station, call was rejected and requested to relog once you are in town.” Complaint lodged against printer failure “Pls refer my attached mail and confirm If you want to repair the same printer.
Already you are rejected to repair the same printer ….one more things our engineer is not consumed any ink because hardly we are attended your calls 2 times only.
Complaint lodged against printer failure still I am waiting your confirmation that you want to repair or Not
Complaint dt 21.12.2017
Printer Head failure / Printer Nozzle missing was reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 which was confirmed by Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh
The Epson Service Engineer Mr Sunil Dubey accompanying with Mr Devendar Singh attending the aforesaid complaint offered the customer to take back a refund for the defective printer stating that the problem lies due to non repairable manufacturing defect and of recurring nature, “You had logged the call but not allowed and supported engineer to check the printer, you had removed all ink from the printer and not allowed to check for any trouble other than color mismatch which you repeatedly reporting.
But understand that you were demanding the replacement of the same issue of color mismatch but replacement will not meet your expectation which is beyond the specification of the printer.”
“False claim, Service Center never denied onsite support. FYI call was attended by our engineer Mr Devendar Singh on 21.12.2017.”
Complaint dt 26.12.2017
Service engineers denied to onsite warranty at the cost of you opposite party number 1.
Service engineers opposite parties number 13 and 14 above infringed the privacy of the consumer and acted fraudulently against the interest of the consumer. When our engineer was tried to take the Photograph you also denied the same and stopped to take the photograph …you are also not signing on call report also ….
Today Engineer visited at Customer side found CIS Tank is empty, and Customer is not ready to provide INK for repairing purpose.
(Concocted service remarks already objected by email)
15) That a Nozzle failure was already notified by Epson service engineers you opposite party number 10 above on dt 21.12.2017. The aforesaid Epson printer model L380, Serial number X2Q5246838 was handed over to you opposite parties number 10 and 11above for repairing on dt 21.12.2017 and on dt 26.12.2017.
And it was the absolute responsibility of Epson Service Center you opposite parties number 6 to 9 along-with you opposite parties number 10 and 14 to carry and bring with them sufficient quantity of Epson original ink, good quality media and other necessary Epson components required at the point of onsite warranty for wastage, testing and replacement during repairing of aforesaid Epson printer within warranty period. Moreover it was also the absolute responsibility of you opposite parties number 6 to 14 to conform free supply all requisite basic requirements and components to the consumer during onsite warranty for repairing from the Epson authorities you opposite parties number 1 to 5.
16) That the printer Head failure / printer Nozzle missing was reported against the aforesaid Epson printer on dated 19.11.2017 which was confirmed by (Epson service engineer Mr Devendar Singh) you opposite party number 10 above on Customer Service Report issued on dt 21.12.2017.
Print Nozzle check pattern report was taken out from the aforesaid printer at page number 1102 by you opposite parties number 10 above and also signed by you opposite party on dt 21.12.2017 but onsite repairing was denied and a cash refund was offered by you opposite parties number 11 who accompanied with Service Engineer Mr Devendar Singh you opposite parties number 10 above.
You opposite party number 11 above (being Epson Service Engineer Mr Sunil Dubey) did not suggest onsite repairing and asked the complainant to opt for a cash refund which was a fraudulent attempt on his part to escape from the complaint against deficiency in services. The customer was also misguided by you opposite parties number 11 to sign a request for that on Customer Service Report dt 21.12.2017.
Print time with the aforesaid printer being 5 minutes 25 seconds in High quality mode for glossy paper A4 size, which was much higher than company specification for L380 printer model.
Ink was consumed in printer maintenance / head cleaning by visiting Epson service engineers and printer flaws and failure to print accurately with true colors could not be rectified during repairing and head cleaning by Epson Service engineers.
You opposite party number 11 above carried the Epson CD owned by the consumer and did not return customer’s Epson printer software CD back to the consumer on date of his visit i.e. 21.12.2017. He even never received customer’s mobile calls.
Complaint caused due to a non-repairable manufacturing defect and being of a recurring nature could not be resolved in repairing and printer head cleaning by the attending Epson service engineers. A fraudulent denial to replace the aforesaid defective product was made by you opposite party number 10 above.
That you opposite parties number 5 and 7 above accepted through email message for having attended consumer complaints through service engineers only for two times out of 23 call logs onwards 14.11.2017 uptill 03.01.2018.
Consequently, written complaint was lodged through email with Epson Area Manager, Mr Maruti Misra, you opposite party umber 5 above, whereas the customer objected to all misleading and wrong remarks willfully created by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above.
Wherein all call logs recorded in para 4 above were fraudulently reported by you opposite parties number 1 to 13 above as attended with fake, concocted, willfully created and manipulated reports raised against complaints lodged by the customer and a force closure of complaints was made.
Service and repairing report for the aforesaid Epson printer was not updated on Epson Web page.
Customer’s complaints against printer head failure and nozzle missing causing printing of unnatural and fake lining in standard mode along with printer failure to print black and cyan color were fraudulently changed into the record of Epson company by you opposite parties 1 to 14 above, the copy of which emailed by the company DGM Epson India P Ltd New Delhi on 28.12.2017.
17) That you opposite party number 5 above being responsible to fulfill customer support onsite always ill-treated the consumer through concocted email messages, misleading conversation on mobile, by criminal offences of infringing consumer’s privacy within consumer’s premises and private room by making video and voice recording done through you opposite party number 13 and 14 above without knowledge of the consumer. The privacy of third party not related with the matter was deliberately infringed under instigation from you opposite party number 5 above on mobile conversation with his service engineer. Repairing of Epson printer was denied in a pre -planned and illegal manner by the authorities of Epson Company.
You opposite party number 5 above flatly denied to depute any service engineer for onsite repairing of the aforesaid defective product and always remained negligent in performing customer services. You opposite party not only refused to intimate Epson Lucknow Area Office address but also misbehaved with the customer in an abusive manner on 26.12.2017.
The act of deputing service engineers with pre thought malafide intention to willfully make photographs and video recording through you opposite parties number 12 and 13 above, on dt 26.12.2017 clearly shows a pre thought planning for not getting the printer repaired and to safeguard you opposite party number 5 above from customer’s complaint against entire ink consumption by visiting service engineers during multiple Head cleaning on previous dates of complaint and to put the customer to monetary losses.
(email message dt 26.12.2017sent by you opposite party
number 5 above already sent by email)
18) That printer Head cleaning and repairing was done with ink consumption from the aforesaid printer ink tank during repairing and multiple head cleaning by you opposite parties number 13 and 14 above on dt 26.12.2017, but the aforesaid printer failed to properly print document with jpeg files in standard quality mode and continued producing fake linings with fake color.
Wherein Head cleaning report was also generated by you opposite parties but you opposite parties refused to repair the defective printer onsite leaving the complaint unresolved irrespective of the fact that the aforesaid printer contained original ink supplied by Epson company after multiple head cleaning by the you opposite parties number 10 to 14 above.
You opposite parties number 13 and 14 above Mr Sandeep Pandey and Vinod Kumar being the Service engineers, acted unlawfully on dt 26.12.2017 as a visiting engineer in privacy area of the consumer not being publically visible. You opposite parties acted illegally with a pre thought motive to deny repairing under warranty, misbehaved with the consumer, infringed the privacy of customer’s family members being third party under instigation and mobile conversation with you opposite party number 5 above on dt 26.12.2017.
Further you opposite party number 13 and 14 above illegally made a video and fabricated voice record after provoking the victim without his knowledge and consent which they should not have done as service engineers, and the second, that you opposite parties attempted to record video of victims family members and belongings inside private room within premises of the customer for which they were not a party, performed a criminal offence latter published that information in public through emails with a motive to causing annoyance / inconvenience, to deceive and to mislead the addressee and recipient.
Head cleaning and repairing was done with ink consumption and report was generated by you opposite party number 13 above. When asked by the customer to record all requisite columns of Epson Service Report as Reported problem, Observed problem and Rectification details you opposite parties willfully left the same blank to deceive the consumer. You opposite parties even did not ssue Epson Customer Service Report to the consumer. It implies a well thought and preplanned intention on the part of the Epson Service Center Engineers you opposite parties number 12 and 13 above under instigation from Epson authorities you opposite parties number 3 to 5 above to commit a crime for not attending to repairing of the printer, which is clear from the message emailed to the consumer by Epson Area Manager Mr Maruti Misra you opposite party number 5.
Service Report Columns as Reported problem, Observed problem and Rectification details willfully were left blank by you opposite parties to illegally make consumer’s warranty claim null and voide, in spite of Head cleaning and repairing being done with ink consumption from the aforesaid defective Epson printer and Head Cleaning report generated by you opposite party number 10 above.
Since the aforesaid printer failed to print document with jpeg files properly in standard quality mode and continued producing unnatural and fake linings with fake color, the consumer recorded his remarks against unresolved complaint on back of the Epson Customer Service Report RMA number INW5003215105 issued by the service engineer.
(Customer Service Report RMA number INW5003215105
already sent by email)
19) That the willful refusal to repair the defective printer by by you opposite parties 1 to 14 above on dated 21.12.2017 and on dated 26.12.2017 is considered as unfair trade practices and an illegal act for making null and void customer’s warranty claim for replacement of defective Epson printer for which the customer was legally entitled for.
The customer informed of the aforesaid printer to contain original Epson ink supplied by you opposite party number 1 above and also asked you opposite parties number 1 to 14 on dt 29.12.2017 to supply ink and submit the bill after repairing and also requested to you opposite party number 4 above through email, which you opposite parties number 1 to 14 have unlawfully denied on grounds that original ink was not available with you opposite parties number 6 to 13 above.
You opposite parties number 1 to 14 above even failed to inform the customer as to what quantity of printer ink was needed by you opposite parties number 6 to 14 each time they attend customer's complaint and how much quantity of ink was to be consumed to avoid repairing / replacement of the aforesaid defective and not working Epson printer.
20) That repair and complaint status for the aforesaid Epson printer illegally remained unavailable against each and every complaint number at Epson web page https://customer.epson.co.in/customer/repair.do#/IN and complaint status was never displayed on site by you opposite parties nuber 1 to 14 above.
Moreover the attending Epson Service engineers never issued the consumer any Epson Service Report / Job Card with printed serial number.
21) That after sale service warranty was all the times denied by you opposite parties against the agreed terms and conditions of onsite repairing or replacement of defective material / product with service ink and further illegally demanding to supply the consumer with unlimited amount of extra bottles of ink other than that contained in aforesaid printer ink tank. Services bought from the opposite parties remained terminated even due to refusal to supply original Epson ink by you opposite party number 1 to 14 above against valid cash memo.
You opposite parties number 1 to 14 never informed the customer nor replied when asked through email message as to the quantity of ink was required and the shop selling Epson ink. You opposite parties even failed to inform the customer as to what sort of repairing was to be done with aforesaid printer and attempted to escape from all complaint call logs made by the consumer.
Whereas, the consumer also visited you opposite party number 6 above with the aforesaid defective and non-working Epson printer and requested to deposit the same with you opposite parties number 6 to 9 above, but you opposite parties refused to do so.
22) That there had been a deficiency in services on the part of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above. You opposite party number 4 above created a willful illegal force closure of all unattended and unresolved complaints with concocted, manipulated, misleading and fake remarks in Epson company records at your end, copy of which was sent by to the consumer by you opposite party number 4 above by email dt 28.12.2017 denying onsite warranty for replacement of the defective product.
(Refer to concocted service remarks dt 28.12.2017 already sent by email)
23) Wherein onsite repairing being willfully denied by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above, a warranty claim for replacement of the defective product was made by the customer through written letter dt 19.12.2017 sent by India Post on dt 21.12.2017 and a request was made to consider the same within 15 days of the date of this letter i.e. on or before 04 Jan 2018 with you opposite parties number 1 and 6 above, but all in vain.
(Mailing proof, Postal receipt dt 21.12.2017 already sent by email)
24) That you opposite parties 1 to 14 above failed to provide uninterrupted / deficiency-less services to the consumer / complainant. Deficiency in services of continuing nature persisted with aforesaid Epson printer as frequent production of unnatural and fake lines in printing through the aforesaid Epson printing machine and of access to machine failure continued since 14.11.2012 up till dt 03.01.2018.
25) That you opposite parties being involved in practice of "planned obsolescence" - creating and selling products pre-designed for failure at some point and to lapse warranty period so that consumers be enticed to replace the product within warranty period and without any extension of warranty period.
And by using this techniques for placing a product on the market pre-designed for failure deliberately aimed to reduce Inkjet printers lifetime in order to increase the replacement rate, you opposite parties are responsible for the same. You opposite parties are involved in selling ink jet printers with pre-designed Head and Nozzles which fails and blocks prematurely even when "substantial ink" remains in the printer tank. You opposite parties by being involved into the breach of contract with its customer who is entitled to use all the ink in the ink tank trouble free. The aforesaid Epson Inkjet printer sold to the consumer is an evidence to that and the consumer is a victim of that.
26) That you opposite parties were all the time negligent after receiving repeated and continued complaints and reminders in making good on-site under warranty claim made by the customer against the recurring and non-repairable manufacturing defect of the aforesaid defective and non-working Epson printer and even thereafter whenever the complainant visited you opposite parties 6 to 9 personally for removal and resolution of complaints against deficiency in service and service failure.
27) That you opposite parties number 1 to 14 deliberately recorded (1) Print lead / Lamp warranty end date (2) Spare part warranty end date and (3) Labor warranty end date to be 27/09/2018 instead of 23.10.2017 based on the date of online delivery to the consumer on dt 24.10.2017.
You opposite parties have willfully terminated the contracted service since 14.11.2018 up till the printer remains dead and warranty made null and void defrauding the consumer.
28) That there had been a deficiency in services from the side of you opposite parties’ number 1 to14 above. Consequently final complaint was lodged by the complainant on dt 03.01.2017 through customer care number against printer failure, service failure, writing off all previous complaints with concocted and fabricated remarks, deficient services, fraudulent acts and unfair trade practices on the part of the service provider respondent / you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above being directly and vicariously liable.
29) That the customer / complainant also requested you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above vide letter dt 19.12.2017 to do the needful to replace the above mentioned defective Epson L380 printer under warranty claim by another working Epson Printer in any brand with equivalent price and value on or before 04.01.2018 and to extend the warranty of the aforesaid Epson printer for a period the complaint remained unattended and unresolved, but all in vain. Onsite repairing of the aforesaid printer has been flatly and directly denied by you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above by applying unfair trade practices for which you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above may be held liable into the court of justice.
30) That the complainant is a consumer of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above through Consumer / Customer No IN7004582980, under Section 2 (d) of Consumer Protection Act 1986 and there is a deficiency of service on the part of you opposite parties number 1 to 14 above as stated in para number 5 to para number 29 of this letter.
You opposite parties number 1 to 14 above have willfully attempted to lapse the warranty for the aforesaid defective printer since 14.11.2017, caused the customer with a great monetary loss of Rupees 11,987/- being the price of the aforesaid printer paid, a sum of Rupees 5,000/ as typing and communication charges paid, loss through paper and media damages Rs 1000/-,, loss through ink wastage Rs 1056/-, loss through postal communication and internet charges Rs 2000/-, a sum of Rs 200,000/ being the amount of loss goddwill, and a sum of Rs 10,00,000/- through mental tension and agony total amount being Rs 12,21,043/- (Rs twelve lac twenty one thousand forty three only) along with other losses to be accessed by the legal advisor which you please are requested to pay to the consumer / complainant / undersigned within 3 days of the date of this letter i.e, on or before 14.01.2018 failing which the consumer shall be bound to refer the matter to his legal advisors for further legal action and compensation of all losses and damages caused by you parties into the matter on risk and responsibility of you opposite parties.
Krishna Deo,
(Consumer / Complainant)
10 January 2018
Annexures as above already sent by email.